The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz

Pub. Date: 11-May-2021
Rating: 4 Stars

The Plot is most definitely one of those books you just can’t put down. Such a lovely slow burn and the ending, well it just smacks you in the face. Highly inventive and truly addictive!

Jacob “Jake” Finch Bonner is a ‘has been’ writer. He wrote one novel that was received well by the critics and had lukewarm commercial success followed by a couple more that should never have been published. He is now drowning in self-pity and unable to write another book worthy of print. Instead of writing, he is now teaching writing at a MFA program at Ripley. One of his students is an arrogant asshole but he does have a killer idea for a novel that is sure to be an instant success.

Years go by and the book is never published. Jake stars wondering what happened. By doing a little research on his computer, he discovers that his former student is dead. Such a shame to let a fabulous idea go to waste and he rationalizes that a plot can’t be copywrited. He will not use any of his student’s words, not that he can remember much after all this time has passed, everything will be his own except for the basic plot. No will ever know, until they do.

The day he has been dreading has finally arrived. While on the road to promote the book, aptly named “Crib”, he receives a message through his author website that simply says, “You are a thief.” Other messages follow, then a Facebook post, even a message at his home. The cat is out of the bag and there is no way to put it back. Jake is now obsessed with finding out more about his former student. What he uncovers is shocking and leads to a chilling conclusion.

This is not one of those thriller that you are totally engrossed in from page one. It was more like a speeding train, it took time to build up energy but once it got going there was no stopping it. I appreciated that the author took her time with this story because it allowed the reader to get an in-depth look into the life and mind of Jake. Something I miss in some thrillers and just the kind of pacing I adore.

I felt the character of Jake was perfect for the story. It needed a character that was self-doubting and so insecure as to be cringe worthy in order to make the story really sing. While the whining would have normally driven me crazy, in this case it gave me feelings of empathy for Jake and I found him very relatable.  

Fabulous story, great characters and the pacing is just the way I like it. I was starting to get bored with thriller type novels; however, this book has reawaken my love for the genre. Highly recommend to all readers.

I received a free copy from the publisher in exchange for my honest opinion.

Saint X by Alexis Schaitkin

Pub Date: 18-Feb-2020
Rating: 3 Stars

Well, Saint X, by Alexis Schaitkin, was not what I expected. I was thinking this would be a thriller with lots of action to pull the story along.  I was very wrong. It read more like literary fiction and the plot was agonizing slow.

The story opens on the fictitious Caribbean island of Saint X. Where Claire, age 8, arrives with her older sister Alison, age 18, and their parents. The vacation precedes along uneventful and the family is enjoying the five star resort and all the amenities until Alison goes missing.

The small island is combed for clues to no avail. After numerous days of searching, two tourists take a short boat ride to the uninhabited island just off the coast of Saint X and discover Alison’s body. The key suspects in the case are two employees of the resort where the family is staying. After questioning them, they are released because at the time of the Alison’s death they were in jail. Therefore, Alison’s death just becomes another unsolved mystery.

Skip forward a number of years and Claire is now an adult and working for a publishing company in New York City. Life seems to have moved on for her. All that changes with a chance encounter with one of the suspects, Clive, or GoGo as he was known on the island. Claire is haunted with the past and becomes obsessed with finding out the truth.  She stalks Clive and then inserts herself into his life. Will Clive be able to give her the answers she is seeking?

Can a story suffer from over development? Absolutely! This is what happened here. I understood Claire and her desperate need to have answers. The author gets the reader inside the characters’ heads. Yet, it became too much in the end.

The rich descriptive prose that I started out loving became burdensome in the end. I got to the point I just wanted the story to move on. I only finished this book because I wanted to know what happened to Alison. In short, too verbose for my tastes.

I have read some of the other reviews and know that a lot of people loved this book. I just was not one of those people. I think it was of case of the wrong book for me. I suggest you read some other reviews before you decide if this is a book for you or not.

I received a free copy from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.